# The Forfeited Pay Buyout Run, Vest Schedule to a Signed Make-Whole Clause

*Build a dated forfeiture ledger, price each line pre-tax, pick cash, grant, or start-date shift per line, and confirm the buyout terms in the re-issued offer.*

- Canonical URL: https://www.refolk.ai/candidates/guides/forfeited-pay-buyout-make-whole
- Pillar: Offers and negotiation
- Format: Playbook
- Published: 2026-11-15
- Last reviewed: 2026-11-15
- Reading time: 23 min
- Keywords: negotiate sign on bonus for unvested RSUs, new employer buy out unvested equity, leaving before annual bonus payout ask new employer, make whole sign on bonus calculation, how to ask for a buyout grant in an offer

## Key takeaways

- Public SEC offer letters price replacement equity on a trailing average close, 20 trading days at SLM and 45 at Tenneco, so a ledger priced on today's spot price can shrink when the employer reprices it.
- Compare a forfeited bonus or RSU tranche with a cash sign-on gross to gross, because both are taxed as supplemental wages withheld at a flat 22%, or 37% above $1 million.
- A gross-basis clawback like TriNet's can make you repay 100% of a sign-on you only received about 70.35% of after the 29.65% flat withholding, so check the word gross before signing.
- Price an open ESPP period at the lost discount only and unvested 401(k) match at the unvested employer balance only, because ESPP contributions are refunded and your own deferrals are always vested.
- Executive make-wholes such as Visa's replicate forfeited pay in value, form, and timing, so ask for replacement grants that vest no slower than the schedule you leave, not an Aramark-style 3-year cliff.
- In Refolk's index of professional profiles, 4,562 US profiles carry a compensation analyst title against 214 in stock plan or equity administration, so assume your ask is read by a document-driven analyst.

This is the run for a candidate who holds an offer and would forfeit unvested stock, an unpaid annual bonus, unvested 401(k) match, or an open ESPP period by leaving now. It takes you from your own grant agreements and plan documents to a dated forfeiture ledger, a priced make-whole ask, and a re-issued offer letter that states the buyout's amount, payment date, vesting, and repayment terms. Run it between the offer and the signature, not on the call.

## What a make-whole buyout covers

A make-whole buyout is the new employer's payment for pay you forfeit by leaving: unvested equity, a bonus you will not be employed to receive, unvested employer retirement contributions, and the discount on an open ESPP purchase. It replaces value you lose. It is not a raise, and the best public precedent says it should copy the forfeited pay in value, form, and timing.

Terms used throughout:

- **Forfeiture:** pay you lose because you are not employed on the date it vests or pays out.
- **Vest schedule:** the dates on which granted shares or employer contributions become yours.
- **Make-whole:** any combination of cash and equity meant to replace forfeited pay.
- **Replacement grant (buyout grant):** new-employer equity sized and scheduled to replace forfeited equity.
- **Cash sign-on:** a one-time payment, usually repayable if you leave within a set window.
- **Clawback:** the repayment obligation attached to a sign-on or buyout.

Two public standards set the bar. Visa's proxy describes awards "structured in value, form and timing to replicate compensation that he forfeited." The UK Investment Association's Principles of Remuneration say a committee compensates "awards from their former employer on no more than a like-for-like basis," reflecting "the present value, vesting periods and performance expectations of the forfeited awards." Both are executive-level. I use them as the method because they are the only written standards, not because every employer follows them.

#### The four lines of a forfeiture ledger

1. **Unvested equity** - RSU tranches vesting after your last day, from grant agreements and the vest portal
2. **Annual bonus** - A payout you miss if the plan requires employment on the payout date
3. **Unvested 401(k) match** - The employer portion not yet vested under the plan's cliff or graded schedule
4. **Open ESPP period** - The purchase discount you lose, not the contributions, which are refunded

*Each line has its own source document and its own forfeiture rule, so each is priced separately before anything is added up.*

What is not forfeited matters as much. Your own 401(k) deferrals are always vested. ESPP contributions are normally returned to you, "normally without interest." Leaving those out of the ledger keeps the ask honest, and an honest ask is easier for the other side to approve.

## What proof does a new employer ask for?

No published US standard says what employers check before approving a buyout, so that is not established. The safe assumption is that they will want the same documents you need to price the ledger: grant agreements, a vest schedule, the bonus plan and last payout, and the retirement and ESPP plan documents.

Here is what is documented in practice:

- A UK practitioner guide says the remuneration committee "should also keep the evidence: award statements from the previous employer and the valuation schedule."
- A candidate-side guide lists "a screenshot of your current equity vesting portal showing the exact number of shares vesting in the next 6 to 12 months" and "your prior year's bonus payout statement or current year's target bonus letter showing the payout date you will miss."
- Another says to provide "a vest schedule showing the unvested equity you're leaving behind - share count, vest dates, and current value."
- Discover's executive offer letter refers to agreements with the current employer "that have been provided to Discover (the 'Provided Agreements')." The forfeited agreements were part of the deal file.

| Line | Source document | What it proves | How it misleads |
|---|---|---|---|
| RSUs | Grant agreement, vest-portal screenshot | Share count and vest dates | Portal shows spot value, not a trailing average |
| Bonus | Bonus plan, prior payout statement | Target and payout date | Plan may say discretionary, so the payout isn't guaranteed |
| 401(k) match | Summary Plan Description, plan statement | Vesting schedule and unvested balance | Statement total includes your own vested deferrals |
| ESPP | Offering document, purchase dates | Next purchase date you will miss | Contribution balance looks like value but is refunded |

Redact account numbers and anything personal that does not bear on the forfeiture. Keep share counts, dates, plan clauses, and payout dates visible. Those are what the reviewer prices from.

## How to price each forfeited line on one basis

Price every line pre-tax, gross to gross, with one stated basis per line: shares at a trailing average close, the bonus at target or prior payout, the match at the unvested employer balance, and the ESPP at the lost discount only. Write the basis next to each number so the reviewer can reprice it without guessing.

| Line | Price it at | Leave out |
|---|---|---|
| RSUs | Shares x trailing average close | Spot price on a peak day |
| Bonus | Target or prior-year payout, stated which | Bonus the old employer must still pay |
| 401(k) match | Unvested employer portion on the statement | Your own deferrals |
| ESPP | Discount on the missed purchase | Contributions, which are refunded |

### RSUs: pick an averaging window and show spot alongside

Public offer letters do not use spot price. SLM priced its replacement on "the average closing price of your current employer's common stock for the twenty (20)" days. Tenneco used "a 45-trading day average stock price" and added a 20% premium on in-the-money options. The averaging window is itself a term you can negotiate. A longer window smooths out spikes, which can help or hurt you depending on where the stock has been. Compute both the 20-day and 45-day averages, show the spot value for reference, and propose the basis you can defend.

### Bonus: read the plan, then check your state

Whether a missed bonus is a buyout line depends on how it is classified. "In many states, an employer may legally require an employee to forfeit a bonus or commission if the employee is no longer employed on the date the bonus or commission is to be paid. In other states, these types of forfeiture provisions are expressly prohibited."

- **New York:** "bonuses that are objectively calculable, nondiscretionary or contractually guaranteed may be deemed 'wages' under New York law and cannot be withheld." In *Weiner v Diebold Group* (1991), earned wages could not be contracted away.
- **California:** "Under California Labor Code § 200, non-discretionary bonuses are legally classified as 'wages.'" However, "an employee who voluntarily resigns before that date may forfeit the bonus."
- **Other states:** a full list is not established in the sources I used. Check Troutman's state survey of post-termination bonus forfeiture rules, or ask an employment lawyer in your state.

If the plan's employed-on-payout clause is valid, the bonus really is forfeited and belongs in the ledger. If the bonus is earned wages the old employer owes, take it off the ledger and claim it from the old employer instead. Price it at target or at last year's payout, and say which.

### 401(k) match: unvested employer dollars only

Match can vest "as slowly as a 3-year cliff or 6-year graded schedule (IRC §411(a)(2)(B))," and "the Summary Plan Description (SPD) your employer provides specifies the exact schedule." Under a 6-year graded schedule, "an employee with three years of service is 40% vested." One worked example puts a $90,000 earner's loss at up to $5,400 just before a 3-year cliff.

Graded vesting is not always the gentler schedule: "from year 3 through year 5 the graded schedule costs more than the cliff, not less," because the cliff is fully vested at year 3 while the graded schedule is still partly unvested. Read the schedule, find your next vesting anniversary, and price the employer dollars that would vest on it. Reading these amounts off a specific provider's statement is not covered in public guidance, so if your statement does not split vested from unvested employer money, ask the plan administrator in writing.

### ESPP: the discount, nothing else

When you leave mid-offering, your unused contributions "will be returned to you, normally without interest." A Section 423 plan may still purchase if the purchase date falls within three months of termination, but "most plans do not permit this." Check your plan's offering document. What you forfeit is the discount you would have received on the purchase. Purchases are capped at $25,000 a year, which also caps this line.

### Why gross to gross

"Supplemental wages are pay outside your regular wages, such as bonuses and RSU income." A cash sign-on is supplemental too. At the time of writing, IRS Publication 15-B sets federal supplemental withholding at 22%, or 37% on supplemental wages above $1 million in a calendar year. Social Security (6.2% up to an annual wage base that changes every year) and Medicare (1.45%, plus 0.9% over $200,000) apply on top. Because both sides are ordinary wages, the tax cancels out in the comparison. Re-check the current rates and wage base in Publication 15-B before you rely on any net figure.

> **Rule:** One basis per line, pre-tax, written down
>
> Every ledger value states its basis (which average, which payout year, which statement date) and is pre-tax. A number without a stated basis gets repriced on the employer's basis, not yours.

## Cash, replacement grant, or start-date shift: which instrument for each line?

Match the instrument to the line's date. Lines that would pay out soon go to cash or a later start date. Lines that would vest over years go to a replacement grant that vests no slower than the schedule you forfeit. Small lines get folded into a larger instrument that is already being negotiated.

This follows the pattern in executive make-wholes, which copy form and timing as well as value. Replacement grants follow the forfeited schedule, and cash covers short-dated items. Tenneco shows the folding move: it added about $10,000 of retirement benefits into its make-up grant rather than paying them as a separate line.

#### Choosing the instrument for a ledger line

Horizontal axis runs from Forfeit date soon to Forfeit date far out. Vertical axis runs from Small line to Large line.

| Quadrant | What it means |
| --- | --- |
| Large and soon | Ask for cash on first payroll, or move the start date past the vest or payout |
| Large and far out | Ask for a replacement grant on a schedule no slower than the forfeited one |
| Small and soon | Move the start date if it is cheap for both sides; otherwise add to the cash sign-on |
| Small and far out | Fold into the replacement grant, as Tenneco did with retirement benefits |

*The line's size and how far away its forfeiture date sits decide whether it becomes cash, a grant, a later start date, or a folded-in amount.*

A start-date shift is the cheapest instrument for the employer. It costs them no cash and needs no approval from the people who sign off equity. If a tranche vests or a bonus pays shortly after your current start date, ask to move the start date first. Then ask for money only for what is left.

Here is how public make-whole clauses actually split the instruments:

| Company (year) | Valuation basis | Replacement vesting | Cash part |
|---|---|---|---|
| SLM (2020) | 20-day average close | 40/40/20 over 3 years | none stated |
| Tenneco (2017) | 45-day average, +20% on options | restricted shares | retirement ($10k) folded into grant |
| AMD (2023) | target value $12M | time-based RSUs | $2M within 30 days, 2-year prorated clawback |
| GE Vernova (2026) | $14.5M LTIP | RSUs 33/33/34, PSUs 3-year cliff | $5M, full repayment within 12 months |
| Aramark (2015) | Fair Value $1.0M | 3-year cliff | none |

Source: SEC EDGAR exhibits. Search for "make-whole" or "forfeited" in EDGAR full-text search to find more.

Expect the first answer to come in under your number. A Bogleheads poster reports a first offer of $0.7X against $X unvested. The ledger is what lets you close that gap line by line rather than splitting the difference.

## The buyout run, step by step

The run takes eight steps, from the written offer to the re-issued letter. Every step after the first produces something you can show the employer.

#### Forfeited pay buyout run

1. **Get the written offer** - Get the offer in writing with an expiry date before you put a number on the forfeiture. Done means a document with a sign-by date and a start date you can count from.
2. **Pull the source documents** - Collect grant agreements, a vest-portal schedule, the bonus plan and last payout statement, the 401(k) SPD and statement, and ESPP offering dates. Done means every forfeited line has a document behind it.
3. **Build the dated ledger** - List every RSU tranche, bonus payout, vesting anniversary, and ESPP purchase date after your proposed last day. Done means each row has a date, a quantity, and a forfeiture rule.
4. **Price each line on a stated basis** - Shares at a trailing average, bonus at target or prior payout, match at the unvested employer balance, ESPP at the discount. Done means one pre-tax basis per line, with spot shown alongside.
5. **Choose the instrument for each line** - Short-dated lines to cash or a start-date shift, long-dated lines to a replacement grant on a matching schedule, small lines folded in. Done means every row names its instrument.
6. **Send the written ask** - Email the ledger, instruments, and redacted evidence to the person who made the offer. Done means every number is traceable to an attached document.
7. **Track the employer's approval** - Expect the compensation team to reprice on its own basis; answer questions from the ledger. Done means a revised number in writing.
8. **Check the re-issued letter** - Confirm amount, payment date, vesting, repayment basis and proration, acceleration without cause, and any offset clause. Done means every ledger line maps to a clause.

**Timing.** The offer is day 0. Sources disagree on when to raise the buyout. One says "wait for a written offer, calculate exactly what you're leaving behind." Another frames the ask after the verbal offer. I side with the written offer, because the start date and expiry date are what you count forfeitures from. If you only have a verbal offer, it is fine to say a buyout ask is coming, but hold the number until you have it in writing. Pulling documents takes about a day in my estimate, though that is not established. How long employer approval takes is also not established publicly. Ask the recruiter for the sign-by date to be extended if your ask is still pending close to it.

### The forfeiture ledger

**Forfeiture ledger**

```
FORFEITURE LEDGER
Prepared: [date]    Proposed last day: [date]    Offer start date: [date]
Share price basis: [20 / 45]-trading-day average close ending [date] = $[x]  (spot on [date] = $[y], for reference)
All values pre-tax.

Line | Source document | Forfeit date | Quantity | Forfeiture rule | Basis | Pre-tax value | Instrument asked
RSU tranche 1 | Grant agreement [ID], vest portal screenshot | [vest date] | [shares] | unvested shares lapse at termination | shares x average | $[ ] | cash / start-date shift / grant
RSU tranche 2 | Grant agreement [ID] | [vest date] | [shares] | unvested shares lapse at termination | shares x average | $[ ] | replacement grant, same vest dates
Annual bonus | Bonus plan section [ ], prior payout statement | [payout date] | [target %] | employed on payout date required | [target / prior payout] | $[ ] | cash
401(k) match | SPD vesting section, statement dated [ ] | [vesting anniversary] | unvested employer balance | [cliff / graded] | statement value, employer portion only | $[ ] | fold into grant or cash
ESPP | Offering document | [purchase date] | contributions to date | refunded, no purchase after termination | discount only | $[ ] | fold into cash

TOTAL pre-tax: $[ ]
Of which: cash $[ ]  |  replacement grant $[ ]  |  removed by start-date shift $[ ]
```

*One row per tranche, payout, or vesting date after your proposed last day; delete lines that do not apply.*

### The written ask

**Make-whole ask email**

```
Subject: [Your name] - forfeited compensation and start date

Hi [name],

Thank you for the offer. I'm keen to accept, and there's one item to settle first. Leaving on [proposed last day] means I forfeit compensation that vests or pays out after that date. I've set it out line by line in the attached ledger, with the source documents (redacted).

In short:
- [n] RSU tranches vesting between [date] and [date], valued at $[ ] on a [20]-trading-day average close
- My [year] annual bonus, payable [date], which the plan forfeits if I'm not employed on that date: $[ ] at [target / last year's payout]
- Unvested 401(k) match of $[ ] that vests on [date]
- The discount on the ESPP purchase on [date]: $[ ]

What I'm asking for:
1. Moving my start date to [date], which covers [line] at no cost to you.
2. A cash sign-on of $[ ] to replace [short-dated lines].
3. A replacement grant of $[ ] vesting on [dates], matching the schedule I'm forfeiting.

All figures are pre-tax. Happy to walk your compensation team through any line, and to use a different averaging window if you have a standard one.

Could you confirm by [date], given the offer's [expiry date]?

[Name]
```

*Send to whoever extended the offer; keep the numbers identical to the attached ledger.*

## What the re-issued offer must say about the buyout

A re-issued offer that includes a buyout should state six things: the amount, the payment date, the vesting schedule, the repayment basis and proration, what happens to the grant if you are terminated without cause, and whether an offset clause can reduce the buyout. If any of these is missing, ask for it to be added before you sign.

The common pattern is a 12-month clawback, prorated monthly or daily, paid on the first payroll or within 30 days. The variants are where the money is:

| Filer | Paid | Clawback | Proration | Basis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Vital Farms | first payroll | 12 months | daily | net after-tax |
| Tenneco 2020 | about Feb 28, 2021 | 24 months | 100% then 50% | net |
| Intuit 2009 | within 30 days | 12 months | 1/12 per month | pre-tax |
| TriNet | within 30 days | 12 months | 1/12 per month | gross, repay in 10 days |
| 4D Molecular | two installments | 12 months each | days/365 | unverified |

Other clauses worth knowing:

- **AMD:** cash "subject to repayment on a prorated basis if Ms. Hu's service terminates within two years."
- **GE Vernova:** $5M cash repayable in full on resignation within 12 months, with RSUs and PSUs "both accelerating on a termination without Cause."
- **MarketAxess:** the company may cut its make-whole awards if the former employer's awards survive after all.
- **Discover:** ties the buyout to the "Provided Agreements," so the documents you supplied define what was replaced.

Read the letter clause by clause against these questions:

1. **Amount:** does the dollar figure, or the share count and pricing date, match the agreed number?
2. **Payment date:** first payroll, within 30 days, or installments?
3. **Vesting:** do the replacement grant's dates match or beat the forfeited dates line by line?
4. **Repayment:** how long is the window, is it prorated or all-or-nothing, and is it gross or net?
5. **Acceleration:** does the grant vest if you are terminated without cause?
6. **Offset:** can the buyout be reduced if your old employer pays out or accelerates?

## How a buyout run goes wrong

Most failed buyout runs give a number that looks right but breaks when someone checks it: the employer reprices it, the repayment terms quietly change its value, or a line was never forfeited in the first place. Each failure below has a check you can run before you send the ask or sign the letter.

1. **Spot price at a peak.** *Looks like:* the ledger is priced on today's close after a run-up. *What happens:* the employer reprices on a 20- or 45-day average and your number shrinks, which looks like a cut. *Check:* compute spot and both averages, and lead with the average.
2. **Gross versus net repayment.** *Looks like:* a 12-month clawback that seems standard. *What happens:* below the withholding limits, flat withholding totals about 29.65%, so you keep about 70.35% of the payment. Under TriNet-style gross terms you could still owe back 100%. *Check:* search the letter for "gross" and "net."
3. **Bonus counted as "earned".** *Looks like:* treating a nondiscretionary bonus as a buyout line, or treating a forfeitable one as wages the old employer owes. *What happens:* you either ask the new employer for money the old one owes, or you chase a wage claim you do not have. *Check:* read the plan text and your state's rule.
4. **ESPP priced at contributions.** *Looks like:* the ESPP line equals your contribution balance. *What happens:* the reviewer sees refunded money in the ask and trusts the rest of the ledger less. *Check:* price the discount only.
5. **401(k) priced on the total balance.** *Looks like:* the match line equals the full account. *What happens:* the same credibility hit, because your deferrals are always vested. *Check:* use the unvested employer portion from the statement or SPD.
6. **Double recovery.** *Looks like:* your old employer accelerates or pays out after you resign. *What happens:* an offset clause like MarketAxess's or Discover's reduces the buyout, possibly after it was paid. *Check:* find the offset clause and know what triggers it.
7. **Replacement cliff longer than the forfeited schedule.** *Looks like:* a grant of the right size that cliff-vests at the third anniversary, as Aramark's did, against a forfeited quarterly vest. *What happens:* the money is right but the timing isn't, and leaving before the cliff forfeits everything again. *Check:* compare vest dates line by line.
8. **No acceleration term.** *Looks like:* the letter is silent on termination without cause. *What happens:* if you are let go, the replacement grant lapses, and you have lost the same pay twice. *Check:* ask for acceleration on the GE Vernova model.

> **Watch out:** A gross clawback can cost more than the sign-on paid you
>
> If the letter says repayment is on a gross basis, leaving early means repaying tax that was already withheld. Ask for net-basis repayment, as Vital Farms and Tenneco used, or daily proration to limit the damage.

**29.65% - Flat withholding on a supplemental payment below the limits**

You keep roughly 70.35% of a cash sign-on, which is why a gross-basis clawback is not a symmetric deal.

> A buyout that matches the money but not the vest dates has only replaced half of what you forfeit.

## Who reviews a buyout request on the employer side

Expect your ask to be read by a compensation analyst who prices from documents, with an equity specialist involved less often. How buyout reviews are actually routed inside employers is not established publicly, so treat this as a picture of who exists, not of who signs.

**4,562 - US profiles titled Compensation Analyst or Senior Compensation Analyst in Refolk's index**

Against 214 US stock plan or equity administration profiles, roughly 21 analysts for every equity specialist.

| Segment | Profiles | Senior share in sample of 25 |
|---|---|---|
| Comp Analyst, US | 4,562 | 9/25 = 36% |
| Comp Analyst, UK | 64 | 3/25 = 12% |
| Stock plan / equity admin, US | 214 | n/a |

The senior share comes from a sample of 25 profiles per segment. The US to UK ratio is about 71x, but the index's UK coverage may be thinner, so read that as an index figure, not a measure of the labour market. Among the US equity administration profiles, the top employers include Apple and UBS, with two each. That is too few to generalise from.

What this means for the ask: the person reading it is more likely a generalist pricing a ledger than a specialist who already knows your old employer's plan. Make every line readable on its own, with share counts, dates, and plan clauses visible. If the reviewer has to come back with a question, the deal slows down and may get repriced on their basis instead of yours.

> **Tip:** Offer them your averaging window and accept theirs if it is close
>
> Ending the ask with an offer to use their standard averaging window costs little when your 20-day and 45-day numbers are near each other, and it removes the most common reason to reprice.

## Before you sign, and keeping the ledger current

Before signing, every ledger line should match a clause in the re-issued letter, and every clause should have a date you can put in a calendar. After signing, keep the ledger until the last clawback window and the last replacement tranche have passed, because the buyout's value depends on dates that are still ahead of you.

#### Buyout sign-off check

- [ ] Every ledger row has a source document, a forfeit date, a quantity, and a forfeiture rule.
- [ ] Every value is pre-tax and states its basis, with spot price shown next to the trailing average.
- [ ] The bonus line has been checked against the plan text and your state's forfeiture rule.
- [ ] The ESPP line is the discount only and the 401(k) line is the unvested employer portion only.
- [ ] The re-issued letter states the buyout amount and the payment date.
- [ ] Each replacement grant tranche vests on or before the matching forfeited date.
- [ ] The repayment window, proration method, and gross or net basis are written in the letter.
- [ ] The letter says what happens to the replacement grant on termination without cause.
- [ ] You have found any offset clause and know what event triggers it.
- [ ] The signed letter, ledger, and evidence are filed together where you can find them at the clawback deadline.

Keeping it current after you start:

- **Calendar the clawback end date** and each replacement vest date from the letter, not from memory.
- **Watch your old employer's plan.** If it accelerates or pays out a forfeited award, an offset clause may apply. Tell the new employer in writing rather than waiting for them to find out.
- **Re-read the plan documents if you are asked to start early.** Moving the start date back can bring forfeitures back that a shift had removed.

If the employer refuses the buyout and the ledger says the offer loses money, decline it in writing and keep the ledger. The next employer will want the same documents, with dates rolled forward. [Refolk](/candidates) helps on that side: it tailors your resume and cover letter to each posting and scores how well you actually fit. That way you can save buyout negotiations for offers where your fit is strong enough to justify the ask. When the next offer arrives, reprice the ledger from fresh portal screenshots and the current average close, and check the IRS withholding rates in Publication 15-B, because both change. Refolk keeps the application side moving while you do that.

## Frequently asked questions

### How do I negotiate a sign-on bonus for unvested RSUs?

Ask for a buyout priced from your vest schedule, not a round number. List every tranche that vests after your last day, multiply shares by a trailing average close (public offer letters use 20 or 45 trading days), and attach the vest-portal screenshot. Ask for cash only for tranches vesting soon, and a replacement grant on a matching schedule for the rest. Then check the repayment terms before you sign.

### Will a new employer buy out my unvested equity?

Some do, and public SEC filings show the pattern at executive level: SLM, Tenneco, AMD, GE Vernova, and Aramark all wrote make-whole awards into offer letters. How often employers grant buyouts below executive level is not publicly established. Expect a reduced first offer; one forum poster reports an initial offer of 0.7 times the unvested value. A documented ledger gives you the strongest footing to close that gap.

### Should I ask the new employer to cover my annual bonus if I leave before it pays out?

Yes, if your bonus plan says you must be employed on the payout date, because then the bonus is genuinely forfeited. First read the plan text and check your state: in New York, objectively calculable or nondiscretionary bonuses may count as wages the old employer cannot withhold, and California treats nondiscretionary bonuses as wages. If the old employer owes it, do not ask the new one to pay it.

### Is a cash sign-on better than a replacement grant?

Cash suits forfeited pay that would have paid out soon. A replacement grant suits equity that would have vested over years, because it matches the forfeited schedule. Cash is usually clawed back if you leave within 12 to 24 months. A grant only pays out as it vests, so check the cliff and whether it speeds up if you are terminated without cause.

### Do I compare the buyout to my forfeited pay before or after tax?

Compare before tax, gross to gross. RSU income, bonuses, and sign-on payments are all supplemental wages, withheld at the same flat federal rate, so the tax treatment cancels out. Converting one side to net and leaving the other gross is the most common way a ledger understates or overstates the ask. The exception is repayment: check whether a clawback is owed on the gross or net amount.

---

*From the Refolk guide library. I revise these guides rather than replacing them, so the current version is always at https://www.refolk.ai/candidates/guides/forfeited-pay-buyout-make-whole*
